Advantage 02

Every km gets cheaper.

Every MMC km uses the same standard components, made in volume on one production line and installed by the same method. MMC is modular and one standard technology across the globe, so the cost per km falls as volume and repetition grow. The evidence from others:

What MMC proposes.

Every MMC km uses the same standard components, made in volume on one production line and installed by the same method. MMC is modular and one standard technology across the globe, so the cost per km falls as volume and repetition grow. The evidence from others:

One set of parts, seven models

Number of each part per pylon, at standard height. — not used. * assumed.

MMC-VCMMC-VCMMC-VBMMC-VBMMC-VAMMC-VAMMC-VDMMC-VDMMC-TBMMC-TBMMC-TB GuyedMMC-TB GuyedMMC-TAMMC-TA
Cutter head12221*1*2*
Anchor latch12221*1*2*
Caisson ring5*16*20*20*5*5*10*
Caisson head12221*1*2*
Tension tubular (~12 m)261286*6*12*
Pylon joint (~3 m)2*10*24*14*18*18*36*
Pylon cap————1*1*—
Tension lock12221*1*2*
Cross beam / cross-arm1253111
Longitudinal beam3102515———
HVDC arm—6126———
Aqueduct wall panel——2*————
Guy wire and anchor—————3—

China.

The World Bank found China built 350 km/h lines for about US$17–21 m per km, against US$25–39 m in Europe, and credited the standardised design and casting of bridge beams, and scale.1 Its 2019 study states: "A key factor keeping costs down is the standardization of designs and procedures."2

Metro stations.

Copenhagen's metro stations are 70–80% standardised; every Second Avenue Subway station in New York was unique.3

Repetition.

A review of building and construction works found a repetition effect of 6–12%.4

The MMC parts.

On the MMC structure.

Every precast part is made one way, at the Megafactory and the Spokes: a die-cast skin over a rib, with concrete injected between them. The same parts build all seven models.

MMC-DWG-003-14 Manufacture: Skin, Rib and Die
MMC-DWG-003-14 · Manufacture: Skin, Rib and Die. Skin and rib made at the Hub; injected at the Spoke. Select to enlarge.

Manufacture →   Modular components, parts per km →   Economics: cost and pricing →

References.

  1. World Bank, Cost of high-speed rail in China one-third lower than in other countries, press release, 10 July 2014. www.worldbank.org
  2. World Bank, China's experience with high-speed rail offers lessons for other countries, press release, 8 July 2019. www.worldbank.org
  3. Transit Costs Project, Final Report, NYU Marron Institute, 2023. transitcosts.com
  4. Gottlieb and Haugbølle, The repetition effect in building and construction works: a literature review, SBi report 2010:03, 2010. vbn.aau.dk
← 01 · Cost per km03 · Many services, one cost →