Advantage 09

Minimal footprint. The land stays in use.

MMC proposes the elevated corridor as the lowest-impact way to carry rail, power, water and services across a continent. At ground level there are pylon bases only: farms, waterways and wildlife keep moving underneath.

What MMC proposes.

MMC proposes the elevated corridor as the lowest-impact way to carry rail, power, water and services across a continent. At ground level there are pylon bases only: farms, waterways and wildlife keep moving underneath.

MMC-VC · caisson footprint
~0.05 ha/km

40 pylons per km × one 4.0 m caisson each = ~503 m² per km. Derived; assumptions below.

MMC-VB · caisson footprint
~0.1 ha/km

40 pylons per km × two 4.0 m caissons each = ~1,005 m² per km. Derived; assumptions below.

HS2 Phase One · land acquired
~31 ha/km

About 70 km² for 225 km of new line, including depots and replacement land. The 2009 estimate assumed a 120 m corridor, about 12 ha/km. Per-km figures derived.1,2

China · Shijiazhuang–Zhengzhou
69%

Share of the line on viaduct, chosen to limit land taken from fertile plains.3

Ground rail is a barrier to wildlife.

Railways act as physical and behavioural barriers; fencing reduces collisions but increases the barrier effect, so it has to be paired with wildlife passes.4

Viaducts are already used to let wildlife through.

California's high-speed rail line is fenced, and one of its main wildlife measures is converting ground-level sections to viaduct.5 On the Qinghai–Tibet railway, all 1,660 Tibetan antelope counted on the 2004 westward migration passed under the Wubei Bridge.6

No continuous earthworks.

MMC is built pylon by pylon: caissons are drilled and installed with no rotation, and the deck is assembled from precast components. There is no continuous cut-and-fill embankment along the route.

Basis and assumptions.

Assumptions for the MMC figures. 25 m spans (40 pylons per km); caisson ring 4.0 m outside diameter (12.6 m² each); MMC-VC one leg per pylon, MMC-VB two. Counts the caisson at ground level only: it excludes construction access, any fencing at pylon bases, stations and depots. The HS2 figure includes depots and replacement land, so the two are not like-for-like; they show the order of difference, not an exact ratio.

On the MMC structure.

The ground take is the caisson at each pylon base, one every 25 m. The deck stays level over the ground, so there are no continuous earthworks, cuttings or embankments, and the land under the corridor stays in use.

A level deck is also a flat, steady line. Hyperloop needs one; the two ways to give it one are elevated or underground. MMC is the elevated way.

MMC-DWG-002-07 Across Terrain
MMC-DWG-002-07 · Across Terrain. The deck stays level; pylons take up the ground. Select to enlarge.

Land take

Land disturbance is concentrated at the pylon foundations: about 12.6 m² for each 4.0 m caisson, one per leg, at pylons 25 m apart on the viaducts (40 per km) and about 200 m apart on transmission towers. Between pylons the ground stays as it was: vegetation, hydrology, soil and micro-topography.

For a 2,000 km corridor (derived): the caissons occupy about 1.0 km² for MMC-VC (one leg per pylon) and about 2.0 km² for MMC-VB (two legs). For comparison, HS2 Phase One in the UK acquired about 70 km² for 225 km of new line, about 31 ha per km including depots and replacement land; at that rate 2,000 km would take about 620 km². Its 2009 estimate assumed a 120 m corridor, about 12 ha per km, or 240 km² over 2,000 km.1

Assumptions: 25 m spans; caisson ring 4.0 m outside diameter; flat ground. Counts the caisson at ground level only: excludes construction access, any fencing at pylon bases, stations and depots. The HS2 figures include depots and replacement land, so they are not like-for-like with the caisson figure; they show the order of difference.

The path under the viaduct

The space under the viaduct can carry a continuous path for cycling, walking and riding, the full length of the corridor, sheltered from sun and rain by the deck above and separated from the moving lines by height. It sits inside the corridor footprint, with no extra land.

Runoff, light and noise

Hyperloop →

References.

  1. UK National Audit Office, Investigation into land and property acquisition for Phase One of HS2, 2018. www.nao.org.uk
  2. UK Department for Transport, Full Business Case: HS2 Phase One, 2020. assets.publishing.service.gov.uk
  3. Ollivier, Sondhi and Zhou, High-Speed Railways in China: A Look at Construction Costs, World Bank, China Transport Topics No. 9, July 2014. openknowledge.worldbank.org
  4. Barrientos and Borda-de-Água, Railways as Barriers for Wildlife: Current Knowledge, in Railway Ecology, Springer, 2017. link.springer.com
  5. California High-Speed Rail Authority, Wildlife Movement fact sheet, c. December 2023. hsr.ca.gov
  6. Xia et al., Effect of the Qinghai–Tibet Railway on the migration of Tibetan antelope, Oryx 41(3), 2007. www.cambridge.org
← 08 · Safety and security10 · Rail-delivered construction →